| 1876 | | Carly Simon F/ James Taylor, Cissy Houston | |
| 1877 | | Carly Simon F/ James Taylor, Jackson Browne | |
| 1878 | | Carly Simon F/ James Taylor, Luther Vandross | |
| 1879 | | Carly Simon F/ Jimmy Webb | |
| 1880 | | Carly Simon F/ John Travolta | |
| 1881 | | Carly Simon F/ Julia Simon, Sally Taylor | |
| 1882 | | Carly Simon F/ Kate Taylor | |
| 1883 | | Carly Simon F/ Linda Ronstadt | |
| 1884 | | Carly Simon F/ Linda Ronstadt, Libby Titus | |
| 1885 | | Carly Simon F/ Lucy Simon | |
| 1886 | | Carly Simon F/ Lucy Simon, James Taylor | |
| 1887 | | Carly Simon F/ Lucy Simon, Jimmy Ryan | |
| 1888 | | Carly Simon F/ Lucy Simon, Joanna Simon | |
| 1889 | | Carly Simon F/ Lucy Simon, Judy Collins | |
| 1890 | | Carly Simon F/ Luther Vandross | |
| 1891 | | Carly Simon F/ Marc Cohn, Ben Taylor | |
| 1892 | | Carly Simon F/ Mick Jagger | |
| 1893 | | Carly Simon F/ Mike McDonald | |
| 1894 | | Carly Simon F/ Mindy Jostyn | |
| 1895 | | Carly Simon F/ Otis Redding III, Dexter Redding | |
| 1896 | | Carly Simon F/ Paul & Linda Mccartney | |
| 1897 | | Carly Simon F/ Paul % Linda McCartney | |
| 1898 | | Carly Simon F/ Ringo Starr | |
| 1899 | | Carly Simon F/ Rita Coolidge | |
| 1900 | | Carly Simon F/ Roberta Flack | |
Indie/Pop/Rock
Indie/Rock
Pop
Hip-Hop/Rnb
Hip-Hop
Soul
Country/Folk
